Apple iPhone 4S Latest Review
The Mark9 Apple iPhone 4S review is finally here! In the 16 months from the launch of the iPhone 4, we’ve had antennagate – the iPhone 4 had serious reception issues due to a misjudgment in the placing of its antenna – the unveiling of iOS 5, Apple’s latest mobile operating system, and three versions of Google Android’s Honeycomb OS.
The world’s handset manufacturers have also been playing a fierce game of catch up, releasing a raft of ever-improving smartphones with faster processors and more features, all trying to steal a march over Apple and its seemingly unstoppable freight train of success.
Many T3 readers have told us how they’d forgone the Apple iPhone 4 because of reported signal problems, or were tied into long 3GS contracts. They were itching for something new. Something special. Something worth waiting for.
So, when Phil Schiller, senior vice president of worldwide product marketing at Apple, took to the stage to announce the long-awaited ‘iPhone 5′ last week, he needed to pull something big out of the iBag.
What we got was the iPhone 4S. The most powerful iPhone Apple has ever made, yet criticised by many as nothing but a cosmetic upgrade.
So how different is it and, crucially, is it worth upgrading? We’ve been living with the iPhone 4S, iCloud and iOS 5 for a few days. Here’s what we think, in a few words…
Apple iPhone 4S Review: Unboxing
Out of the box, the iPhone 4S looks identical to its older sibling bar the distinguishing birthmark of a brace of top-mounted incisions signifying that a new antenna design lurks within. Switch on the phone, however, and things are different.
Unless you’re restoring the data from an older iTunes backup, the 4S doesn’t require a computer for activation. You can restore the phone from an iCloud account, or set up as a new phone. If you don’t have an Apple ID, you have the option to create one.
iCloud can also be activated from the phone for storing and wirelessly pushing photos, apps, contacts, calendars to and from your 4S. The whole process, whether restoring from iTunes or setting up fresh, takes less than five minutes. And because it’s the same case design, iPhone 4 users can just swap over their SIM card.
Unfortunately, in-app information isn’t transferred, so you’ll need to re-enter login details, re-download offline Spotify playlists and re-affirm personalised settings in every app that requires it. An obvious security measure by Apple, but it was these actions that took the longest to complete.
Apple iPhone 4S unboxing video
The Apple iPhone 4S Review: Hardware changes (processor)
Many iPhone 4 owners will be asking themselves why they need an iPhone 4S when the free iOS 5 upgrade will equip their current phone with most of the new 200-odd features. We’ll get into the meat of those features later, but know this: Apple has built its best phone to date.
The new A5 dual-core processor (as seen in the iPad 2) makes things noticeably nippier. Apps launch quicker, web pages load faster, multi-tasking is more fluid and resource-hungry apps like Pages now allow you to edit documents without any lag. Competitors will argue that their phones have been able to produce similar results for months, and they’d be right, but it remains a welcome (if a little late) upgrade.
The processor also supercharges the iPhone 4S’s graphical prowess. We tried Real Racing 2 HD and, while the visuals were a little smoother, we didn’t notice the 7x improvement as claimed by Apple. This is because games will need to be tuned to take advantage of the new chip. We had a demo of Infinity Blade 2 (confirmed to launch later this year) at the iPhone 4S launch and were blown away by the detail and speed of the polygon pushing. We’re talking PSP Vita graphics, if not better.
Another benefit of having the A5 processor is to mirror 4S content over AirPlay. Wirelessly, the 4S will push out 720p to an Apple TV. Over connected HDMI, that will jump to 1080p. The simplicity of pushing small-screen content to the big screen on the fly is a neat trick, especially when you start rotating and zooming. It’s also something to brag to iPhone 4 owners; T3 was told that the older model simply can’t cope with the demands of such technological wizardry.
The potential for playing games on the big screen from your phone is something Sony and Nintendo should keep an eye on, too. Note that, in our demo, the super-charged Infinity Blade 2 was jumpy over wireless. Tiny Wings has never looked better, though.
Apple iPhone 4S vs Apple iPhone 4 video
The Apple iPhone 4S Review: Antenna
Antennagate rocked Apple’s world for the wrong reasons after the launch of the iPhone 4, so we were keen to see how the new design ‘improves call quality’ and ‘reduces risk of dropout’.
Both the 4S’s antennas, which run around the top of the phone, can transmit and receive data, allowing for faster 3G connections. Apple claims that maximum download speed over HSDPA is 14.4Mbps – twice as fast as the iPhone 4.
In the few days we’ve been testing, we haven’t noticed an improvement in call quality and didn’t experience any dropouts. But we have definitely seen faster download speeds over 3G and quicker web page loading. T3.com took an average of 5 seconds to load on the iPhone 4S, compared to an average of 8 on the iPhone 4.
We also ran the SpeedTest app (on O2-UK network) and got an average of 3.34Mbps download and 1.45Mbps upload. On the older iPhone 4, on the same network in the same location, we achieved average results of 2.32Mbps download and 1.31Mbps upload.
We also tried the death grip (for old times’ sake) and didn’t see any signal bars dropping off a cliff. Hurrah.
The Apple iPhone 4S Review: Camera
The camera’s had a major overhaul, now capable of taking eight-megapixel stills and recording 1080p video. Apple claims upgrades to the optics allow for more light, better colours and improved white-balancing. We didn’t dismantle the 4S to find out, but did take a range of shots in a variety of conditions to test the assertion.
Photos are crisper, no question, but it can’t compete with traditional cameras with bigger lenses in low light. You can now choose to have a grid on the screen when taking shots, perform basic image-editing within the Camera Roll and jump straight to the camera function via a shortcut.
Log into Twitter and you can post photos from the Camera Roll directly to your feed. It’s quick and makes a cute tweet sound when sent into cyberspace. Anti-cutes can, however, switch off this slice of audible joy before tucking into their sour-faced sandwiches.
iOS 5 brings with it the option to use the ‘+’ button as shutter when taking landscape shots. Face detection is also an upgrade and works well.
The 1080p, 30fps camera is impressive. Clarity and detail are excellent and the A5 processor allows for image stabilisation of the go. Shaky hand, be gone. We played back footage on our 47-inch TV and, even in full screen, video quality was great. We can hear the home camcorder industry wincing from here.
Sound quality is limited due to the small in-built microphones, but good enough for most things, especially YouTube where videos can be uploaded directly from the 4S. Which leads us onto a point of compromise; with an upgrade in image quality comes an increase in file size and it’s no wonder Apple needed to launch a 64Gb version. You’ll also want to do more uploading and sending over wi-fi as not to upset your network operator and/or bank balance.
Apple iPhone 4S: 10 things to do first video
The Apple iPhone 4S Review: Siri
The main talking point of the iPhone 4S, quite literally, is Siri – a voice-controlled in-built app that acts like your own PA. Hold down the home button to launch Siri and then ask it to perform certain tasks. We barked a variety questions and demands, all with varying responses and success rates, which can be seen as follows:
The command “call my wife” resulted in Siri asking who our wife was from our address book. Once confirmed, repeating the same instruction resulted in a call to the wife. 1-0 Siri.
“What is 477 multiplied by the circumference of the moon?” we asked. Siri consulted the Wolfram Alpha engine and presented an accurate and detailed result. It’s 6786.03 miles, in case you were wondering. 2-0 Siri.
Mark9: “Set a reminder to buy some milk tomorrow” Siri: “Calling Simon now” 2-1 Siri
Nevertheless, what makes Siri so clever is how it can maintain a conversation to perform a task. While driving we asked, through our headphone mic,: “what’s the weather like in London tomorrow?”, to which Siri dutifully replied. ”Rainy”. We then followed with: “And on Sunday?” and Siri was clever enough to contextualise the conversation and give us a report: “Weather for this Sunday is….Rainy.”
You can also have fun with Siri – asking it things like the meaning of life, the meaning of naughty swear words, why Siri exists, or whether Brian Blessed has the loudest voice in human history. The results can be entertaining. We’ll leave you to discover them.
Siri needs at least a 3G connection to operate and we found that Wi-Fi works better. It’s presently in beta, so we’re expecting some improvement as and when updates are released.
Albeit fascinating and entertaining, we don’t think Siri is reason alone to upgrade to a 4S. It’s undeniably amazing technology but we just can’t see how often people will use it. Asking it to do things like “set the alarm for 6.30am tomorrow morning” will save a few buttons clicks, but most things we asked of it are quicker to do manually. Apart from the moon calculation bit.
If you do decide to form a relationship with Siri, a word of warning: your partner will go mental. Smartphones already come between us and our dearest, so striking up a conversation with a robot rather than talking to your beloved, or Siri being the last person you talk to before falling asleep might just be a step too far in today’s society.
Apple iPhone 4S Siri Demo video
The Apple iPhone 4S Review: iCloud
The notion of cloud computing is still a mystery to many and we were pretty skeptical as to how Apple, the maestros of uncomplicated explanation, would decipher this one for the mainstream. But therein lies the genius, you don’t have to understand how iCloud works to get it working or benefit from it. You just need to enter your Apple ID and start using your Apple kit.
Mail, contacts, calendars, reminders, bookmarks, notes, are all updated whenever you make a change. It takes the pain out of worrying where things are and gives you time back. We’re amazed Apple is giving everyone 5GB of storage free, but think an upgrade (and accompanying annual subscription) will be all but necessary for those with a half decent media collection.
iTunes in the Cloud isn’t currently available in the UK so we haven’t been able to test music, movie and app syncing.
PhotoStream is a cool feature of iCloud but we found the time between taking a picture on the 4S and it appearing in our iPhoto stream slow. We’ll update as to whether this was a case of teething.
Apple iPhone 4S: First look video
The Apple iPhone 4S Review: Notifications
Although part of iOS 5, rather than iPhone 4S-specific, notifications are a a great addition to the art of using an iPhone. Run your finger down the top of the screen to bring up a list of your latest feeds from Twitter, Mail, Facebook, calendar and reminders, among others. You can customise what appears in the list and how notifications appear – in the centre of the screen or a banner at the top of the phone. Again, many phones already have this, but it’ll be a welcome first for iPhone fans.
The Apple iPhone 4S Review: Battery
Battery life has also been improved. Apple claims 8 hours of 3G talk time, upto 9 hours of wifi use, 10 hours video playback and 40 hours of musical pleasure. In our experience, we can say that when compared to the iPhone 4, all of these activities had less of a drain on battery. Whether this will still be the case in six months time, we’ll have to see. We did notice the battery draining a little quicker when in standby, however.
Among the 200-odd new features in iOS 5 and other things we’ve noticed thus far, here’s a collection of what’s floating our boat on the iPhone 4S. And what isn’t…
Apple iPhone 4S Review: Mark9 Verdict
So, as previously mentioned, the iPhone 4S is the most powerful and feature-packed phone that Apple has ever made. The camera, processor and antenna are all well-needed improvements. And Siri is eccentric genius, if a little before its time. However, the fact that you can upgrade your old iPhone 4 with a smorgasbord of brand new features for free, with iOS 5 and iCloud, will undoubtedly put many off upgrading to the new phone.
16 months is a long time for the competition to catch up and the iPhone 4S has some serious opposition. However, what no-one else can offer is the colossal, yet slick infrastructure that is iTunes and iCloud. And this may be just enough to coerce those teetering on the edge into opting for the iPhone 4S. What’s more, are people really going to wait another year to see the iPhone 5?
We don’t think so.
It may not be what people were hoping for – whatever that looked like – but the iPhone 4S is now the best phone from the Apple stable. A powerful mobile device with a great OS and some cutting-edge tech to boot
Apple iPhone 4S Review: More news and reviews
In your ultimate guide to all things Apple iPhone 4S related, we look inside to see what’s packed in with your new iPhone in our iPhone 4S unboxing, get a video rundown of the best iOS 5 features and 10 Things to do first with your Apple iPhone 4S. But that’s not all, we have also pulled together an Apple iPhone 4S vs Apple iPhone 4 video plus we see how the new Apple smartphone shapes against T3’s Phone of the Year as we pit two giants against each other in our Apple iPhone 4S vs Samsung Galaxy S2 feature.
1. Apple iPhone 4S: Processor
On the outside, it looks, feels and smells like an iPhone 4. That’s because it is. On the inside, however, is where the S magic really happens. The faster A5 processor makes operating the device noticeably quicker when launching and re-launching apps and when using power-draining applications such as iMovie.
2. Apple iPhone 4S: Design
The plain fact that it looks like an iPhone 4 will be a hammer blow to those who have waited patiently for a freshly designed, potentially cooler-loooking iPhone 5. This tweet from @crossan_phil sums it up: “glad the 5 didn’t come out. Gives me more time to use my 24mth contract with the 4!!”
3. The iPhone 4S: Gaming
The improved graphics are amazing. While the version we used didn’t have Infinity Blade 2 installed, we tried Real Racing 2 which, to us, looked smoother than our iPhone 4 version. The keynote demo of Infinity Blade 2 was mind-blowing considering it was running on a bloomin’ phone. It wowed the room. A room full of cynical hacks. PSP Vita, eat your heart out
4. The iPhone 4S: 8-megapixel camera
The 8-megapixel camera shoots great photos (and macro shots). Although we were inside the Covent Garden Apple store with strip lighting a reflections-a-go-go, the resulting shots were nice and sharp, employing some of that new camera tech built into the iPhone 4S. However, the real star of the vision upgrade is…
5. Apple iPhone 4S: 1080p video camera
The difference in quality is instantly noticeable. We were very impressed. Will it nail the coffin shut on the dwindling camcorder industry? It’s a great upgrade regardless of whether you really need it. Well, cinema pirates might.
6. Apple iPhone 4S: iOS 5
You all know what it’s like, the 200+ features it brings plus the iCloud. However, getting hands on with Notifications, Newsstand, iMessage and Reminders demonstrated to us just how much of a step up from iOS 4 it is.
7. Apple iPhone 4S: Price
Apple has announced entry level UK pricing of £499. We think this is for the 16Gb version, which could put the brand new 64Gb model at a whopping £699 (going by the US pricing structure). We need to confirm that though. Orange and T-Mobile have confirmed that they will be selling the iPhone 4S come October 14, presumably on a two-year contract.
8. Apple iPhone 4S: Speech
Siri is the most interesting feature of the 4S. We asked it the weather in London, and then San Francisco. We gave it a multiplication query. We asked who the prime minister of the UK was. We asked it the meaning of life (‘to answer questions like these’ was the retort). It answered them all.
Some of the replies were even funny. From a damn robot. It also got a few things wrong and we think that, in a real-world environment surrounded by lots of noise, it may struggle. Especially as it’s still in beta. We’re looking forward to testing it further (watch this space). Our long-suffering partners, however, aren’t.
9. Apple iPhone 4S: Antenna
It’s the big question for many thinking of upgrading – will it still fall foul of the reported drop call/signal issue? Apple claims that switching between the dual antennas will improve call quality and reduce dropouts. We didn’t have enough time to try this out, but are looking to putting that and the 2x download speed claim to the test as soon as we possibly can.
10. Apple iPhone 4S: Alternatives
Many smartphones already sport a lot of these features already. And for those who were hoping for a brand-new iPhone 5 today might just now consider a top-drawer Android. They’ll be cheaper, too.
In your ultimate guide to all things Apple iPhone 4S related, we’ve got an Apple iPhone 4S review, a look inside to see what’s packed in with your new iPhone in our iPhone 4S unboxing, a video rundown of thebest iOS 5 features and 10 Things to do first with your iPhone 4S. But that’s not all, we have also pulled together an iPhone 4S versus iPhone 4 video plus we see how the new Apple smartphone shapes against Phone of the Year as we pit the iPhone 4S against the Samsung Galaxy S2.